There are no words. As you all know, I am a Oakland A’s fan, and if you watched any sports channel tonight, you say it. It was horrible. It should not have happened, and something needs to be done about it.
In case you missed it, there was a home run, that wasn’t a home run, but was a home run. In the top of the 9th inning in Cleveland, the Athletics were down 3-4 with two outs, when Adam Rosales hit a game tying solo home run. But he didn’t. Not according to the umpires at least. Upon further review, it was still a home run, but still not according to the umpires. The four members of the umpiring crew in Cleveland, who I should mention have been horrible all series long, took horrible to the next level. After signalling that Rosales’s home run was a double, A’s manager, Bob Melvin came out to ask the umpires to review it as it appeared to be a home run. While the umpires were reviewing the play, we at home were reviewing it to. I don’t know what the umpires were looking at, but they said there wasn’t enough evidence to call it a home run. Are you (beep)ing kidding me?! Every shot I saw showed it was a home run. Fans at the game knew it was a home run, the Indians announcers said it was a home run. Everybody said it was a home run, except the umpires, the only people whose opinion on the matter counts.
I am not a big fan of instant replay, but the umpiring this season is making me rethink this. They seem to be trying to put themselves out of jobs. However, this home run non-call is huge. You have instant replay to get these calls right. There is no excuse for them to have said it was a double after review. Why even have replay if you are going to review it and still get the call wrong? And not just wrong, but no doubt in anybody’s mind, wrong. That makes Major League Baseball look bad, and they should be embarrassed. I have a lot of respect for umpires, they get screamed at, they are out there for every pitch and every play all game long. Today, I lost that respect for four men. It’s a shame.
Take a look yourself, but I do find it entertaining that fans from all over baseball are saying it was a home run and they umpires got it wrong. Adam Rosales’s “Home Run”