Being an Athletics fan is like a roller coaster. Sometimes things are great, and you are flying high. Other times, you are going full speed towards the ground. Much like a roller coaster, this low will soon whoosh up.
Monday, August 1st was the trade deadline and all hell broke loose. Oakland traded Rich Hill and Josh Reddick to the Los Angeles Dodgers in exchange for 3 of their top 15 pitching prospects. I thought we all knew this was coming and would be prepared. I thought wrong. Half of the fans on twitter celebrated the pitching the A’s received, as the pitching in the A’s fan system leaves much to be desired. Half of the fans of Twitter went crazy that Reddick was traded and the owners suck. I sat in the airport waiting for my flight and laughed. I couldn’t understand what I was seeing. The trade needed to be done.
Why I agree with the trade- it needed to be done and was what was best for the team. The A’s were not going to win this year and most likely will not next season as well. It sucks, I know. Anybody that has watched the A’s this season has noticed the constantly changes in starting pitching rotation and the nightmare that has been. Friday’s game against the Chicago Cubs was the issue in a nutshell. The A’s have virtually no starting pitching, especially with players landed on the DL at alarming rates. The trade gave the A’s pitching that they desperately needed. And not just pitching, but the three prospects are all ranked in the top 15 in the Dodgers system. The Dodgers farm system is a strong one, perhaps you have heard of Clayton Kershaw, so this is a major haul. Another reason this is a win, is Reddick’s health. Since joining the team in 2012, Reddick has had extended trips to the DL at least once each season since 2013, which is a red flag. Reddick is also 29, which is not old in real life, but is old in baseball life. Now, Reddick and the A’s were trying to work out a contract extension, but hit a road block in terms of years. A’s wanted 3 years, while Reddick wanted 4 years. For a player that is already 29 and has had extended trips to the DL in the past four years, four years is a major risk for a team. The A’s had another reason to be weary of giving Reddick a four-year extension and that is history.
Let’s take a look at players the A’s have extended and what happened to them. In 2004, the A’s gave third baseman, Eric Chavez, a 6 year contract extension, which he played 451 games of 972 regular season games (46.4%). In the final four years of his deal, starting when he was 29, he played a total of 154 games of 648 regular season games (23.8%). Another player that received an extension was Sean Doolittle in 2014, a five-year contract extension. In 2014, Doolittle appeared in 61 games. The deal sounded great at the time, then the injured bug struck. In 2015, Doolittle appeared in just 12 games and in 2016 so far, Doolittle has appeared in 35 games. Doolittle is currently on the DL, along with 14 other members of the team, including seven other pitchers. I love Doolittle, but it is safe to say, the contract extension fail once again.
Since I mentioned Friday’s game against the Cubs, I have more to say about what I saw. I saw signs saying “SELL”, “Trade Ownership”, and “Fed UP”. I posed the question on Twitter that if you were fed up, why were you there. I received a lot of comments and feed back. To be clear, I was not attacking, I legit wanted to know. I asked because when I am fed up with something, it is dead to me and I want absolutely nothing to do with it, so I couldn’t understand what I was seeing. I also had conversations on Twitter about ownership being cheap. I don’t agree with that 100%. There are plenty of teams that throw money at players, hoping to buy their way to a championship. The A’s have recently been shelling out more money on players in the past few years, unfortunately, they didn’t work out as planned. Jim Johnson struggled from day one and Billy Butler has shown he wasn’t worth the money. If either of those players had worked out, would we be having conversations about the owners being cheap? No. If the A’s had won in 2012, 2013 or 2014, would we be having conversations about trading ownership? No. If the Giants across the bay weren’t winning World Series in 2010, 2012, or 2014, would we be having any of these conversations? No.
2014. Going into the All-Star break, the A’s had the best record. Billy Beane made the infamous trade that nobody will ever forgot or forgive. On our recent ‘On a Wimm Podcast’ we discussed the trade of Cespedes for Lester and Gomes. People point to this as proof that the ownership doesn’t care about wining. That team, like this year, needed pitching. Drew Pomeranz was on the DL with a fractured hand after punching a chair after a loss, Jesse Chavez didn’t have the ability to survive a full season in the starting rotation, and Scott Kazmir was just in his second season since being out of Major League Baseball with injuries. The A’s needed pitching, and Billy went out and got just that. Unfortunately, we know what happened in 2014. Now, if the season had ended differently, where would we be? What if the A’s had continued their reign as best in baseball and won the World Series? Would the trade still be considered a bust? Would the season still be considered a failure? Would we still be saying the ownership wants the team to fail? The answer to all of those questions is no. I should also mention, the Milwaukee Brewers were the second best record in baseball for most of the season as well, and collapsed as well. In the early 2000’s, the A’s had hands down the best pitching rotation in baseball with the big three. Those teams couldn’t get past the ALDS. Ever. So many people wished that Beane had made a trade to get that one piece that those teams needed to push the A’s over the hump, but he never did. Damned if you do, damned if you don’t.
All this being said, I will miss Reddick’s canon of an arm and all out style of play. For those that don’t know, I know somebody that was injured in the Boston Marathon bombing. It was a rough time for all of us. Josh Reddick and Brandon Moss came to the hospital to see him and spent a large amount of time with him. It was an experience none of us will forget. For that, I will always be grateful and in debt to Reddick.